An interesting note about the Sturmey drums...
When I first got mine I was concerned that they didn't seem to be stopping me as well as expected, in fact I couldn't get them to lock up & skid. Wondering if perhaps they were faulty or grease fouled I pulled 'em apart to see, when I found nothing wrong I had a chat with a bike tech friend whom has installed quite a few sets, even using them himself.
To make a long convo short, he said, "nope - that's just the way they are." but that didn't really satisfy me - although it relived my concerns about my bike's excessive weight (
heavy vintage ride) and the effectiveness of the dual-pull brake lever. So I broke out my other MB, V brakes & equipped with "performance" pads that are grabby as all heck and did a few "panic stop" runs, then I did the same w/the dual drum equipped vintage ride...
Oddly enough - the
effective stopping distance was not too different, it took the vintage bike only a tiny bit longer to stop which
might be attributed to the huge weight difference, as the vintage wheelset alone weighs about the same as the entire other bike (minus the engine kit ofc) While the V brakes would GRAB and go into a skid in a heartbeat - that really doesn't help stop in a shorter distance.
I really haven't much of a choice with the vintage ride, with the rims it's got it's drum or disk - and disks would... well... they'd jus' look odd lol, however once I did the stopping distance test I was much reassured about the drum's effectiveness and I'm
really pleased with the lack of pad wear and how well they work in wet conditions.
I think disks are prolly the best brakes available, but I've decided drums are a pretty close second... I'm going to do my best to avoid V brakes with future builds - while the pad wear can be HUGELY reduced with just a set of premium pads, I despise how poorly they work in the rain and even the "simple" matter of having them correctly adjusted so one pad doesn't drag on the side of the rim drives me a lil nuts. It's easy 'nuff to be sure - but it's a constant maintenance I'm happy to not need to do anymore.
*shrug* It's yer call
