One side of the counter weights is wider as that is easily seen.
Of my extra crankshafts, the pics of the two I have show them being the same as far as the counter weights go. Probably will fit in the 3.5 Briggs and then have a longer 3/4 crankshaft for clutch.
The cup rope starter and a matching flywheel cowl, as opposed to the recoil has me concerned though.
I would guess my two crankshafts are also like the heavier crankshaft you have with the short shaft, except the ones I have, have the longer crankshaft.
I don't know if you have exhausted a search for parts, but I may just decide to swap em for something or sell them. You do see they are not nearly as in good condition from pictures we shared. The scratches I mean.
The two crankshafts I have do show different stamped numbers on them, but look similar. Only one thing I did just notice, the more scratched rusty one may have the shaft end for the cups rope starter threads shorter, either for a reason in manufacture, or some one cut it off. As far as I can tell it probably could be used the way it is if the scratches don't matter too much. Maybe you know, what is that little nub after the threads with a dimple in the end of the shaft needed for? Something to do with maybe using a flywheel puller is all I guess.